H.R. 5717, Dealing with Federal Funding for States and Localities

September 20, 2024 | H.R. 5717

Immigration enforcement is important, but singlemindedly prioritizing it over public safety and other law enforcement, as this bill does, is a terrible mistake. Despite being promoted as a vehicle to reduce crime, this bill would have quite the opposite effect. 

Put simply, when working people fear immigration consequences for engaging with local authorities, they are less likely to report crimes. In just one alarming illustration of the far-reaching consequences of this approach, a recent study of counties that actively cooperate with federal immigration enforcement documented a nearly 50% drop in reporting of workplace health and safety violations in key industries, and a corresponding increase in workplace injuries by roughly 24%. Clearly, when we allow conditions in which workers are afraid to file claims, we endanger workers physically and deepen the risk of other such workplace crimes as wage theft, discrimination and sexual harassment, which already are far too common.

Legislative Alert

This is Bad for working people.

Vote result: Passed

YEAs: 219
NAYs: 186

Legislator Sort descending State District Party Vote
Rep. Ralph Norman
SC
5 Republican Yes
Rep. Zach Nunn
IA
3 Republican Yes
Rep. Jay Obernolte
CA
23 Republican Yes
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
NY
14 Democrat No
Rep. William Ogles
TN
5 Republican Yes
Rep. Ilhan Omar
MN
5 Democrat No
Rep. Burgess Owens
UT
4 Republican Yes
Rep. Frank Pallone
NJ
6 Democrat No
Rep. Gary Palmer
AL
6 Republican Yes
Rep. Jimmy Panetta
CA
19 Democrat No
Rep. Chris Pappas
NH
1 Democrat No
Rep. Nancy Pelosi
CA
11 Democrat No
Rep. Mary Peltola
AK
At Large Democrat Yes
Rep. Greg Pence
IN
6 Republican Yes
Rep. Scott Perry
PA
10 Republican Yes
Rep. Scott Peters
CA
50 Democrat No
Rep. Brittany Pettersen
CO
7 Democrat No
Rep. August Pfluger
TX
11 Republican Yes
Rep. Dean Phillips
MN
3 Democrat No
Rep. Chellie Pingree
ME
1 Democrat No