Amendment to Circumvent Collective Bargaining Agreements

Jun. 21, 2012 | S.Amdt. 2166 to S. 3240
Under the guise of "strengthening" workers' collective bargaining rights, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) offered an amendment to the Farm Bill that would give employers the right to circumvent provisions on wage increases in collective bargaining agreements, supposedly to allow for merit raises. But under current law, unions and employees can and often do link pay increases and performance as merit-based increases. Nothing in the RAISE Act links pay or benefit improvements to individual achievement or success; rather it eliminates current built-in protections against favoritism, cronyism, and arbitrary action by employers. The amendment was defeated.

This is Bad for working people.

Vote result: Failed

YEAs: 45
NAYs: 54

Legislator State Sort ascending Party Vote
Sen. John Barrasso
WY
Republican Yes
Sen. Michael B. Enzi
WY
Republican Yes
Sen. John D. Rockefeller IV
WV
Democrat No
Sen. Joe Manchin III
WV
Democrat No
Sen. Herb Kohl
WI
Democrat No
Sen. Ron Johnson
WI
Republican Yes
Sen. Maria Cantwell Democrat No
Sen. Patty Murray Democrat No
Sen. Patrick J. Leahy
VT
Democrat No
Sen. Bernard Sanders
VT
ID ID No
Sen. Jim Webb
VA
Democrat No
Sen. Mark Warner
VA
Democrat No
Sen. Mike Lee
UT
Republican Yes
Sen. Orrin G. Hatch
UT
Republican Yes
Sen. John Cornyn
TX
Republican Yes
Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison
TX
Republican Yes
Sen. Bob Corker
TN
Republican Yes
Sen. Lamar Alexander
TN
Republican Yes
Sen. John Thune
SD
Republican Yes
Sen. Tim Johnson
SD
Democrat No